November 2019

CEER Newsletter


Our latest publications cover a range of activities including our forward-looking proposals to support the decarbonisation of Europe’s energy sector; guidance to companies and regulators on bundled products; and our detailed monitoring of Europe’s energy markets.

Two of these are joint ACER- CEER reports:
-    The annual ACER-CEER Market Monitoring Report (MMR). It comprises four detailed volumes on: Electricity Wholesale Markets, Gas Wholesale Markets, Electricity and Gas Retail Markets, and Consumer Protection and Empowerment. There is also a helpful MMR Summary with the key findings for 2018.

In addition, CEER has published the following reports:
-    CEER Guide on Bundled Products, applicable across all sectors (not only energy). It has 10 principles for companies offering bundled products and 3 principles for regulators. Supporters of this Guide include BEREC (the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications) and BEUC (the European Consumer Organisation)
-    CEER’s Monitoring Report on the Performance of European Retail Markets in 2018 which looks (inter alia) at market structure, switching activity and price regulation in Europe.
-    Individual country reports of national regulatory authorities (NRAs), national language version and English summaries.

Slides and photos from our recent events including the CEER Customer Conference, the MMR event, the Bridge Beyond 2025 event and the “Bundled Products: Dispute Resolution & Consumer Rights Enforcement” regulatory roundtable are online.

On 21 November, several CEER electricity market experts met with a GIZ-sponsored delegation from Ghana’s Electricity Market Oversight Panel (EMOP).

CEER President Annegret Groebel was interviewed by the Journal Général de l’Europe this month – read it here.

Save the date (23 January 2020) for our CEER Annual Conference (in Brussels).


Feature: ACER-CEER Bridge Beyond 2025
ACER and CEER have released their thinking on how to decarbonise the energy sector in their “Bridge Beyond 2025” Conclusions Paper.

What is the “Bridge beyond 2025” Conclusions Paper?

The Bridge Beyond 2025 is an ACER-CEER Conclusions Paper that follows extensive public consultation by ACER and CEER. The ACER public consultation focused on issues the gas sector faces in the future and a CEER public consultation focused on regulatory challenges for a sustainable gas sector. The conclusions cover decarbonisation, competition, flexibility and sustainability, as well as the role of ACER and national regulatory authorities (NRAs).

It looks at the status, challenges and proposed regulatory responses across four themes:
•    Theme A: access and market monitoring;
•    Theme B: governance of infrastructure and oversight of existing and new entities;
•    Theme C: dynamic regulation for new activities and technologies;
•    Theme D: transmission tariffs and cross-border capacity allocation.

Key recommendations in the “Bridge beyond 2025” Conclusions Paper?

Regulators recommend updating Europe’s gas sector legislation and to future-proof regulation to facilitate decarbonisation of the energy sector, to promote a competitive Internal Energy Market and to maximise the opportunities arising from sector coupling. The Clean Energy Package (CEP) sets the path to decarbonise the electricity sector. This joint ACER-CEER Conclusions Paper, proposes legislative action (beyond the CEP) to decarbonise the gas sector, and for electricity and gas sector coupling beyond 2025.

Flexibility for decarbonisation

ACER and CEER believe an updated gas legislation should define and categorise decarbonised gases and integrate them into existing gas markets, with full valuation of their environmental benefits. It should also provide regulatory predictability to enable the emergence of new gases and technologies. The Conclusions Paper recommends new investments in natural gas to be assessed in line with the EU decarbonisation targets and that existing assets are evaluated for possible re-use – following consultation with neighbouring authorities and stakeholders – before decommissioning.

ACER and CEER recommend the establishment of a system of dynamic and targeted regulation based on the Gas Target Model (GTM) and the Agency’s market monitoring, as well as the analysis of NRAs. The updated legislation, the ACER-CEER Conclusions Paper says, "…should also facilitate new assets and activities, including a sandbox model at EU level for pilot, small scale projects and appropriate differentiation between competitive and monopoly activities”.

Increasing competition and fighting fraud

ACER and CEER recommend that a technology-neutral level playing field be established between different conversion and storage facilities so that they face equivalent treatment of costs, and equivalent recognition of environmental and security of supply benefits. For infrastructure planning, the improvements in network code governance introduced in the CEP for electricity are needed in the gas sector as well, in particular, better regulatory oversight over entities which may have an interest in promoting infrastructure investments.

With regard to tariffs, both regulators and stakeholders find that, at present, “tariff design does not appear to be causing major issues at a pan-EU level. However, legislative changes can unlock better regulatory tools to address barriers to trade”, the Conclusions Paper notes.

Transmission System Operators (TSOs) and NRAs currently face difficulties to act in an effective and timely manner to deal with fraud. ACER and CEER propose several ex-ante measures, which can contribute to mitigating the risk of fraudulent behaviour.

Why the name “Bridge beyond 2025”?

The ACER “Energy Regulation: A Bridge to 2025”, published in September 2014, set out regulators’ thinking on appropriate regulatory responses to the challenges in the electricity and gas sectors over the coming decade. Several of our recommendations were subsequently addressed by Europe’s co-legislators in the (2019) Clean Energy Package.  This new “Bridge Beyond 2025” paper provides regulators view of legislative action (beyond the CEP) to decarbonise the energy sector, and for electricity and gas sector coupling beyond 2025. It is hoped that this paper will be helpful to the new the new College of European Commissioners and MEPs as they consider future legislative initiatives in this area.



- ACER-CEER Market Monitoring Report (MMR): Electricity Wholesale Markets, Gas Wholesale Markets, Electricity and Gas Retail Markets, and Consumer Protection and Empowerment. Accompanying the MMR is a Summary and the ACER-CEER Press Release “Energy Regulators recommend legislative and regulatory action to support the decarbonisation of Europe’s energy sector (19 November 2019)
- ACER-CEER Bridge Beyond 2025 Conclusions Paper and CEER Evaluation of Responses on the CEER public consultation focused on regulatory challenges for a sustainable gas sector
- CEER Monitoring Report on the Performance of European Retail Markets (21 November 2019)
- CEER Guide on Bundled Products and accompanying CEER-BEUC-NEON Joint Statement (6 November 2019)



Tel Logo +32 278 873 30 or +32 484 668 599

Unsubscribe from the CEER news alerts.